A BLOG of PHILOSOPHICAL REFLECTIONS & SPECULATIONS

Disobedience affirms the order it ostensibly contests

Published on Tuesday May 24th, 2011

Jodi Dean, in Disobedience? Really?:

In this setting of the decline of symbolic efficiency, what can we make of democratic disobedience? It’s not simply that the bad guys occupy the transgressive position, breaking the law, it’s that there is no difference between obedience and disobedience. A recent book exemplifies this point with respect to the last decades of financial malfeasance in the US: ‘the best way to rob a bank is to own one.’ Another way to put it, there’s nothing left about disobedience. The rich and powerful have already swept that possibility away. Or, their illegality and corruption, their use of state law as weapons against the rest of us present those who want to argue in terms of law in the position of defending the very regime or order that works against us. Does it really make sense for leftists to fight in terms of constitutional regimes that are preserving the exploitation of the majority of the people? Lenin’s insight in The State and Revolution remains powerful:

In capitalist society, providing it develops under the most favorable conditions, we have a more or less complete democracy in the democratic republic. But this democracy is always hemmed in by the narrow limits set by capitalist exploitation, and consequently always remains, in effect, a democracy for the minority, only for the propertied classes, only for the rich. Freedom in capitalist society always remains about the same as it was in the ancient Greek republics: freedom for the slave-owners (372).

So I guess I’m back to my first thesis, with a bit of qualification—in the setting of the decline of symbolic efficiency, disobedience affirms the order it ostensibly contests, and this setting is capitalism.

Colloqium

Readers of this post have also read

May 25th, 2011

Crowding out of intrinsic motivations

Luis Villa (lawyer, formerly the "geek-in-residence" of The Berkman Center For Internet and Society at Harvard) reviewed the psychological literature on the impact of paying people for work that they once did as volunteers to determine whether its a good idea for the GNOME Project to offer cash prizes ("bounties") for some code contributions instead of just relying on free labor:…

Read more →
May 25th, 2011

Crowdsourcing Mobile Application Development

Here's a paper called Crowdsourcing and ICT work: A study of Apple and Google mobile phone application developers (PDF). From the abstract: ...developers’ experiences are analysed to illustrate how they cope with increasingly precarious and insecure working conditions and adapt to shifting labour market requirements. It may seem counter-intuitive to think about Android and iOS apps as crowdsourced development, and if…

Read more →
April 11th, 2011

Disengagement is a Luxury

Earlier today I tweeted this link: User-friendliness and fascism - where the conflict between Mac and PC is mapped on to the standard left-right political frame. Macs usually stand for left countercultural values, partly because them simply wrapped themselves in appropriate imagery, but also more substantively. Frankfurt School philosophers argued that technology was a tool of social control and domination, disciplining…

Read more →

Recent Popular Posts

February 13th, 2014

Left Activism Goes Corporate

One of the most tedious features of the Silicon Valley Hype Machine is its endless repetition of progressive sounding marketing slogans about democracy and freedom, all while promoting a pro-business agenda. But it's too easy to read this as a sinister corporate ploy to co-opt the language of activists and twisting…

Read more →
December 20th, 2013

Civility: A Distance That
Brings Us Together

Just in time for the holidays, Apple's marketing department released Misunderstood, an ad about a surly teenager absorbed in his iPhone in the midst of scenes of his family's idyllic Christmas togetherness. But he surprises everyone when he reveals that the whole time he was making a touching video for everyone to document their familial bliss, moving them to tears. A…

Read more →
January 26th, 2014

Ten Parenting Lessons
I Learned from Franz Kafka

Here's an adage which I think is true: every theory of parenting is implicitly a theory of society. It follows that even if you aren't a parent now, nor ever intend to be one, if you're interested in society and culture, you ought to be interested in the topic because the problems that we parents face (or believe we face) is…

Read more →